Only the shafi school accepts it as it does not look at the intentions, which are left to judge by allah, rather they look at the language of the two valid sales contracts. These mechanisms for both have been found unacceptable by the majority of islamic scholars and propose the use of financing based on murabahah and. It can also be applied when a seller sells an asset. The first form is cash financing and cash loan for islamic and conventional banks. Oic fiqh academy resolution 179 195 organized and reserve tawarruq are impermissible. For abedifar et al 2012, islamic finance may still face extra risks because of the complexity of islamic modes of.
Nursyamsiah, tita and kayadibi, saim 2012 application of bay alinah in islamic banking and finance. Bay al inah buy back sale and its position in modern. Bai al inah definition of bai al inah a loan in the form of a sale, called inah facade because it is a sale in appearance only. Bay alinah is a sale contract with immediate repurchase. Iman sastra mihajat,1 safri haliding2 abstract islamic banking product has gained popularity since the last two decades and stole the attention all banking and finance sector industry around the world due to its uniqueness compare to conventional bank and trusted as a solution for the. Thus, the bank, as mustasne, arranges for the second contract, being the parallel istisnaa agreement step 2, with the construction contractor as sane or end sane because it is the ultimate sane in the overall istisnaa parallel istisnaa arrangement. How scholars criticize the practice of bay alinah in malaysia islamic banking bay alinah is a sale contract with immediate repurchase. Their shariah scholars concur that majority of scholars and financial institutions prohibit inah, though wonder the issue as a kind of ijtihad personal reasoning that permits divergence of ideas. The application of bay alinah and bay aldayn in malayisan islamic bonds. One of the foci of this criticism is the application of bay al inah, sales contract with immediate repurchase, in creating a number of socalled islamic financing products.
Dalam urus niaga ini, penjual menjual aset kepada pembeli secara tunai dan kemudian membelinya semula secara pembayaran tertangguh dengan harga yang lebih tinggi daripada harga jualan secara tunai. Both tawarruq and inah are two different developments of murabaha. Bay inah is seen by the maliki and hanbali school according to zuhayli as invalid, and for the hanafi as defective. Shariah and legal issues in house buying in malaysia. In alhaskafi sale of an asset with a motive to generate profit. Pdf on sep 23, 2019, fathullah asni and others published the. Ia merupakan salah satu instrumen2 yang terawal yang diperkenalkan dan telah mendapat banyak sambutan samada dari pihak bank mahupun pelanggan. Bay alinah, bay aldayn and their applications in money.
If otherwise, the application of bay alinah is void. Therefore, most of islamic jurists forbid bai alinah due to loaning intention between the seller. Al salem, islamic financial product innovation, international journal of islamic and middle eastern finance and. The major reasons for this critique is that bai inah, while having an underlying transaction in its structure, argues critics, smells suspiciously like a loan with interest. Bay alistisna is defined as a contractual agreement with manufacturer to produce items with specified description at a determined price and manufactured from his own materials with his own effort. The difference, ostensibly profit, is actually a loan.
If this is not sufficient to convince the proponents of bay al inah, perhaps judgment of the high court in the case of arab malaysian finance berhad vs taman ihsan jaya and ors provides a strong message about the status of bay al inah. The sale and buyback of an asset for a higher price than that for which the seller originally sold it. According to some jurists, inah is defined as a sale of a commodity on credit and repurchasing it for a lesser amount in cash. To bring together expertise and knowledge from iium institute of islamic banking and finance iiibf and kulliyyah of ict kict on a common platform to share knowledge and matching researchers to.
The bay alinah controversy in malaysian islamic banking by amir shaharuddin. According to these schools, bay alinah is valid if there is no plan to apply time period of excessive price volatility. The prospective debtor sells to the prospective creditor some object for cash which is payable immediately. The product of islamic bank for liquidity risk management by. Read online the business school shodhganga book pdf free download link book now. Setelah itu, ia membelinya kembali pada majelis yang sama secara kontan dengan harga yang lebih rendah dari harga jual pertama.
The use of bay al inah in bics operation has gained some controversies among the muslim jurists. Publication effectiveness of qard al hasan financing as a poverty alleviation model. Tawarruq is an arabic word that literally means minted silver or the act whereby some person seeks silver money. Basically, sukuk are simply documents or certificates that represent. Bai alinah also defined as a buy and sell transaction between the same parties over the same merchandise. One of the foci of this criticism is the application of bay alinah, sales contract with immediate repurchase, in creating a number of socalled islamic financing products.
The impact of 911 incident on islamic finance growth perceptions. A seller immediately buys back the asset he has sold on a deferred payment basis at a price higher than the original price. Islamic bankers resource centre discussions on islamic. It is worth noting that the contract of bay bithaman ajil or almnurabahah is instrumental in making the bay alinah transaction possible in the banking. The sac of sc, in its 5th meeting dated 29 january 1997, has resolved that bay al inah is permissible. Bai salam,bai istisna and bai alinah yayasuha prices. One of the foci of this criticism is the application of bay alinah. Definition, application in islamic banking, and some opinions about bay alinah this part elaborates the definition. It should be noted that the theory and application of bay alinah are still subject to debate by the schools of islamic law as the sale involves riba i. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. In other words, tawarruq refers to purchasing a commodity on credit and selling it to a.
The study analyses some products based on bay alinah in malaysia. For many years, malaysia have been taking heat on its use from international forums. Chapter 2bai al inah we do not attempt to overwhelm the reader with a plethora of arabic words and we translate every relevant word in english for ease of selection from contracts and deals in islamic finance. Can use conventional mortgage conditions must be for the buyer must not have another houses must not have surplus funds with which to buy if alternative exists. Bay alinah in the banking sector this part of the article will discuss the existing interestfree banking products in the malaysian market where the contract of bayalinah is applied. Bai alinah is one of the wellknown salebased contracts among islamic financial products.
Jun 19, 2012 opinion of scholars bay alinah is permissible subject to the following condition. The chapter focuses on a certain type of transaction discussed by old muslim jurists and different opinions with variable justifications and reasoning have been arisen on. This is accomplished by ones buying back what one has sold for a lower price than that for which one originally sold it. Bay altaqsid encouraged sale with deferred payment bay al inah not allowed buy and immediate resale what if finance unavailable. Pdf the bay alinah controversy in malaysian islamic banking. The current practice of islamic banking in malaysia has been criticised as insufficiently different from conventional banking. Jul 04, 2015 issuu is a digital publishing platform that makes it simple to publish magazines, catalogs, newspapers, books, and more online. Bai inah contract is still necessary in the context of local islamic. For this reason, it is critical to put things straight. The bay alinah controversy in malaysian islamic banking. This study also discusses about legal device hilah and it relation with bay alinah. Bai inah boleh diertikan sebagai satu kontrakakad yang membabitkan urusniaga jualan dan pembelian semula aset oleh penjual.
Resolution on bai inah islamic bankers resource centre. Ambank employed bay alinah principle to govern its credit card transactions while bimbs worked on the basis of bay alinah. The bay alinah and bay aldayn issues are serious to the islamic financial market movement, as it is not about minor details of religious practices furuq but sadly dealing with the fundamental usul of religion. Bay al inah issue in malaysianur farah fadhlin 248507 nur izzati atikah 248503 bay al inah contract is mean a seller sells an asset to a buyer on a cash basis and later buys it back on a deferred payment basis where the price is higher than the cash priceintroductionbanking sector in malaysia. The business school shodhganga pdf book manual free download. An analysis of the classical and contemporary juristic opinions on bay aldayn pdf by hanudin amina. Islamic bankers resource centre discussions on islamic banking. A user s guide to cash flows, balance sheets, and capital structures book.
Coord of data and information of ibsid definisi bai alinah secara umum dapat digambarkan sebagai berikut. Qard al hasan pdf bound by religious or moral beliefs of the participants, benevolent loan, qard al hasan, is an interest free loan in which only the return of the. What is bai alinah bai alinah in conceptually refers to a sale of an asset. The method used is descriptive and positive analytical criticism which aims at improving the existing structure. Of course the bank is not in the business of constructing houses. Application bay alinah in islamic banking for now, only two countries which are malaysia and brunei darussalam allow bay alinah applying in their banking system. It is a financial product structured to satisfy customer cash needs in accordance with shariah.
Sanusi financial contracts involving use of bay alinah and bay aldayn have been extensively used in design of malaysian islamic bonds. A bayal inah is very similar to tawarruq, but in tawwaruq there will be a third party that is involved in this type of islamic finance as an intermediary. International conference on corporate law iccl 2009 1 st 3rd june 2009, surabaya, indonesia page 1 pelaksanaan bay alinah dalam pembiayaan peribadi personal loan di. Tawarruq as a product for financing within the islamic. If this is not sufficient to convince the proponents of bay alinah, perhaps judgment of the high court in the case of arab malaysian finance berhad vs taman ihsan jaya and ors provides a strong message about the status of bay alinah. There are differing opinions between middle eastern scholars and south east asian scholars, from a shariah perspective, on if a bai. In these transactions, the seller sells an asset to the buyer on cash basis and then buys back the asset at a deferred price which is higher than the cash sale price. Is malaysian islamic home financing bay bithaman alajil. A seller sells an asset to a buyer on a cash basis and later buys it back on a deferred payment basis where the price is higher than the cash price. Application bay al inah in islamic banking for now only. Feb 07, 2017 understanding the concepts of islamic credit cards the borneo post sabah, 3rd july 2017 by dr hanudin amin typically debt taking is of two forms.
Bay alinah free download as powerpoint presentation. According to rosly and sanusi 1999, bay al inah is generally known as sale based on the transaction of nasiah delay. Technically, it is a type of sale contract in which a commodity is bought with deferred payment and sold to a third party a person other than the buyer for immediate cash. The product of islamic bank for liquidity risk management. Sanusi gulf sukuk pick up as idb issues, tdic mandates, reuters, september 9, 2009. Application of bay alinah in islamic banking and finance. Tawarruq means converting an asset into wareq or money. Application the transaction of alinah must strictly follow the mechanism which is accepted by the shafie school the transacted item must not a ribawi item the buyer must receive take possession the good before selling it back to the original seller 9. It takes place when a person sells an asset in credit and immediately buys back the asset in cash at lower price. Bai alinah refer to a contract which involves sale and buy back transactions of an asset by the seller.
Pdf introduction to islamic banking products deposit. Understanding the concepts of islamic credit cards 2. What is the difference bay altawarruq and bay alinah. Download the business school shodhganga book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf. According to sami al suwailem, researchers in islamic finance do not agree on the precise meaning of gharar, although there is not necessarily great difference among the islamic schools of jurisprudence in the terms definition.
In islamic banking, we dance around issues as if vying for a bollywood oscar. It is worth noticing that the contract of murabahah and blogs nearby. Bay al inah is a sale contract with immediate repurchase. Shafii the contract is valid provided that it complies with all conditions of contract. Tinjauan konsep, hukum dan implementasi the sale and purchase of inah and tawarruq is a classic problem that is recognized or not continues to grow and be practiced by individuals and financial institutions to date.
Created using powtoon free sign up at create animated videos and animated presentations for free. Bay alinah adalah salah satu medium yang penting dalam sistem perbankan islam. Bay al sarf is a contract of exchange of money for money. Bai alinah sale with immediate repurchase malaysia a syariah principle involving the sale and buyback transaction of assets by a seller. Tawarruq in islamic finance posted on march 5, 2011 by camille paldi. Request pdf the bay alinah controversy in malaysian islamic banking the current practice of islamic banking in malaysia has been. One of the most controversial contracts that resides in malaysia is the bai inah contract. The selling of an asset with a mark up price on deferred pillars payment, with the intention to sell the same asset to the debtor with lower cash price, which is meant to settle opinion of his debt. This study investigates bay alinah status according to various traditional schools perspective and those of recent scholars. Jul 05, 2018 bay alinah bay aldayn bay alwafa bay alistighlal with the marriage fintech and islamic finance, would the following contracts be phased out. Bay alinah refers to the concept of buying and selling between two parties where the bank sells an asset be it real or fictitious to the customer on a deferred payment and then the financier immediately repurchases the asset for cash at a discount or vice versa.
Tawarruq refers to the purchase and sale of a commodity wherein three different parties are involved. However, it cannot be denied that other factors do play an important role in determining capital flows from middleeastern countries. In this structure, the bank purchases certain goods on spot basis from local or. Some issues of bayalinah in malaysian islamic financial markets.
1420 88 406 1225 642 308 168 544 130 1153 991 462 128 1001 97 105 482 871 1126 1277 89 1369 522 1343 252 188 695 566 552 1291 595 459 687 247 774 638 665 330 274 884 447 608